Moral Versus Personal

I am posting a series of blogs on my favourite Program activity, Inventories. I love them and never tire of them. The benefits are clear and well worth the effort involved. And the more I do, the easier it gets.

Part 1: Spiritual Maintenance
Part 2: Moral versus Personal
Part 3: Writing the Name
Part 4: Special Names
Part 5: Just the facts, ma’am
Part 6: How were you affected?
Part 7: What was my role?
Part 8: The Confessional Conversation

Step Four is a moral inventory, and Step Ten is a personal inventory. An exciting choice of adjectives, moral to personal, moving from Step Four to Step Ten.

Now I don’t want to make too much of this distinction between the adjectives moral and personal. A careful reading of the Big Book and 12 x 12 shows that Bill Wilson did not consider the use of different words to be significant in regard to inventories.

But we should not ignore the differences that can, on reflection, be seen. My experience suggests that there is something to learn by paying attention to the moral in Step Four and the personal in Step Ten.

My early Step Four inventories were moral. Where had I harmed someone? Where had I done something requiring restitution? Where had I been right and where had I been wrong? These are questions framed as – issues of right and wrong, harms and damages.

Later, with Step Ten inventories, I moved from moral to personal. Here is my story.

When I established an annual inventory habit, I followed the classic four-column method Bill Wilson outlined in Step Four in the Big Book. My early grudge lists were people I had harmed. But after the first couple of years, and re-reading with greater care the instructions in the Big Book, I found myself developing a different type of grudge list. This new type of grudge list began to more closely follow the guidelines that he outlined in the four-column Step Four instructions. To quote: “Who made me angry? What burned me up?” I expanded the questions to include relations that were off-putting, I realized that while I was listing relationships that reflected rights and wrongs, damages and harms, I was also listing relationships that left a bad taste, were bothersome, relationships that were on my mind

As I transitioned from a Step Four inventory to a Step Ten inventory, with the shift from moral to personal, the scope of the grudge list expanded. It has become a comprehensive listing of personal, not merely moral, shortcomings.

Related posts

admit one fair ticket

Step Ten Admissions

Step Ten in the AA program teaches the importance of admitting our wrongs. Discover what it means to truly admit ...
Inadequate Clothing

Inadequate Clothing

My wife and I recently holidayed in Scotland. If you are visiting Scotland, you are interested in history or have ...
bouquet of flowers and sheet of paper

Petals and Pages: Turning Over a New Leaf

Simple acts like giving flowers and writing down inventories can create significant shifts in our lives. Dive into this exploration ...

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top
Newsletter

Sign Up!

Get Andy C's latest thought-provoking articles in your inbox.